As I write on Monday morning, the news reports have it that a short-term bailout of General Motors and Chrysler will emerge and be voted on sometime this week. What are the parameters and objectives of the immediate actions that will probably be taken?
The key objective is to prevent an out-of-cash situation at General Motors, and possibly at Chrysler. If nothing is done, it’s more likely than not that GM will enter a process of forced liquidation by the end of this year, mere days from now.
But because this is an emergency situation, there’s been no time to fully debate the issue, and to deal with the fact that no one has bothered to try to convince the American people that their tax dollars should be used to reward a couple of badly-failed businesses.
That heavy lifting indeed will get done. But not in the current Congress and Administration. The can is going to get kicked down the road into January.
And as you’ll see, this outcome is entirely to the liking of the United Auto Workers and their leader, Ron Gettelfinger.
The simplest way to solve the GM emergency is for the government to give them just enough cash to get them through the next two months or so, giving everyone time for some more political horsetrading, and to allow the incoming Democrats to deal with the problem.
Notice, I said the “simplest,” not the “best.” The blockage to this sort of an emergency bridge loan has been among Democrats in the House of Representatives.
Republicans have been proposing for weeks that a chunk of already-appropriated funds be used for a short-term bridge. Since these dollars were originally intended for research on fuel-efficient vehicles, the Democrats have been dead-set against spending them merely to ensure the survival of the automakers.
But late last week, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi signaled that she’d be ok with using some of that appropriation as an emergency bridge, provided that the money would be replaced in a subsequent appropriation, “in the next few weeks.”
So I suppose Republicans will be able to claim a moral victory of some kind, that they were able to force Pelosi to delay a cherished piece of pork-barrel spending for a few more weeks. I’m so impressed.
Now the Bush Administration, for its part, has been pushing this line as well. One supposes that they want more than anything else for the collapse of GM to occur after they’re out of office. Fair enough, I guess it’s a lot to ask for this crew to start showing some leadership now, after we’ve waited in vain for it all these years.
Congressional Democrats really don’t want their fingerprints on yet another bailout, after seeing how well the TARP financial-system bailout went over with the public. So they’ve been pushing hard on the Treasury to use some of those same TARP funds to bail out GM.
They’ve even put pressure on Ben Bernanke to use the “exigency” powers in the Federal Reserve Act to create some cash for GM and Chrysler. Neither Paulson nor Bernanke are expected to bite on any of this. The bridge loan for GM will need to come from Congress.
So the fast and easy outcome will be to vote some kind of emergency bridge, with very few strings attached, and then get out of town for the holidays, leaving the next Congress and the new Administration to finish the job.
This approach has a very big flaw. A fatal flaw.
Keep in mind that the Republicans have an effective majority in the Senate right now. Senators Obama, Biden, and Clinton will probably abstain from voting on a GM package. If we want to influence the outcome, now is our last chance to do it.
And among the very few people in the Capitol who have the right perspective on this, is Senator Corker of Tennessee.
In Senate Banking Committee hearings last week, Sen. Corker pointed out that there’s a big elephant trying to sneak out of the room: the United Auto Workers.
The UAW obviously wants all the pain to be borne by GM’s management, shareholders, bondholders, and of course by the taxpayers.
But Sen. Corker suggested that any near-term bridge for GM must include some strict, binding conditions on the UAW, in addition to the ones that will be imposed on GM (such as firing CEO Rick Wagoner, who seems to have made Senator Dodd’s enemies list).
I can’t stress enough how important this is, and Republican lawmakers MUST MUST MUST follow through on this.
The reason is simple. If the whole mess gets pushed into next year, it will be decided by a Congress and Administration that owe a very great deal to the UAW for their electoral successes last month, not least for delivering Michigan’s electoral votes into the Democrat column.
There will be no significant cost-cutting or pain imposed on the UAW in the restructuring of the domestic auto industry, unless it happens right now, this week.
The UAW must agree to a labor-cost structure that, in Sen. Corker’s words, is no higher than that faced by foreign (“transplant”) automakers who assemble vehicles in the United States. The union must agree to very painful concessions on wages, healthcare, work rules, and retiree benefits.
Gettelfinger, playing to the galleries, has assured lawmakers that he will indeed be open to doing whatever he can to seal the deal. Among other things, he’s signaled willingness to end the so-called “job bank.” You know, that’s where an automaker closes a production facility that no longer makes sense, but continues to pay the workers full wages and benefits to play video games all day, for years into the future.
But what Gettelfinger has pointedly not said, is that he’s willing to re-negotiate the contract that the UAW currently has with the automakers. In short, he’s not preparing to compromise at all, or to ask his people to take any real pain.
If we bail out and restructure the domestic auto industry without forcing the UAW to take their fair share of the pain, I guarantee you that the Big Three are doomed. Without concessions from labor, there’s no conceivable way for Detroit to remain even marginally competitive. Unless we’re prepared to keep putting more and more public money into them, month after month.
Without UAW concessions, a collapse will happen, sooner or later. And the later it happens, the more taxpayer dollars will be wasted in the process.
Senator Corker, we’re counting on you to stick to your guns. Convince your Republican colleagues to make strong UAW concessions a condition of any short-term bridge loan to the Big Three.
KnightsofMalta
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Great analysis as always
mbauer (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 10:02AM EST (link)The thing is, the average american gets this. In every discussion I have with any acquaintance on this matter, we always come to the point that the unions in Detroit can in no way compete with the foreign cars made here in the South due to their unions. Many call for bankruptcy of the big 3 because they see it as the only way to break up the unions and make the companies competitive again. If congress wants to avoid bankruptcy at all cost- the cost must be taking on the UAW. I can proudly say I volunteered hours for Corker’s election a couple years ago.
oops
mbauer (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 10:03AM EST (link)slash the last part of that first sentence…
Proud of Corker
FJG (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 12:50PM EST (link)As a Conservative Tennessean, I am proud of Corker for being the voice of reason and calling out the unions. I will be even prouder if he and the other conservatives can force the UAW to make consessions and the liberals to give up on the idea of using the bailout money or re-imbursing funds that have already been allocated for the auto industry’s use.
As far as I and my family are concerned, this doesn’t redeem Corker for voting for the bailout but this does start the redemption process. We would love to see Corker fully redeem himself and emerge as a strong conservative leader in the senate.
You're too brainwashed by the lib media
Mostpeoplereallyarestupid Monday, December 8th at 4:46PM EST (link)Non-union workers in Toyota and Honda plants here in USA make the same hourly wage as traditional Big 3 workers. New union hires get 50% LESS per hour and no pension. Main difference in employee cost is pensions. Toyota and Honda are too new to have legacy costs (I think Toyota has 120 retirees currently) but that will change over time. The Jap Gov. subsidizes their industry, ours passes regulations that adds costs and burdens the entire industry. Average cost for labor per vehicle is only $600 per vehicle at US assembly plants, why are you so angry about that? The so-called bailout is actually a LOAN, not a giveaway…why are you angry about that!?
The Dems are ALWAYS doing whatever they alledge or complain that the Reps are doing! Never fails to amaze. I laugh so hard.
Because they don't deserve a loan.
asleep06 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:12PM EST (link)And what makes you think a loan will be paid back? Just because They Say So? No, you look at their economic prospects, and when you do so, you realize that it’s not going to happen, especially if the UAW doesn’t agree to lower benefits.
No one has a right to a loan. No one.
Small is beautiful.
:snicker: "Loan", eh?
Bill S (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 6:30PM EST (link)At the rate the Big 3 are burning through cash, how long do you think it’ll take them to repay that “loan?” I’ll be six feet under and worm food by the time any of those companies even entertains the notion that maybe, they MIGHT, want to pay that money back. And what, pray tell, is going to change their revenue/profit/cash flow scenario so that they could even do it if they wanted to?
If you honestly are naive enough to believe that any of the senior executives in GM/Ford/Chrysler plan on paying that money back, well, you fall into the category of your username.
“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins
Health costs are also different.
Flagstaff (Diary) Tuesday, December 9th at 3:58PM EST (link)Health benefits and retirement plans are not the same between the average GM, et al, worker and the furriners, either. Nor are they the same among all US auto workers. Ford and (I imagine) GM and Chrysler installed less lucrative medical and pension benefits for newly hired workers years, even decades, ago. Ford no longer pays health benefits (at least not beyond an HSA) to non-union retirees over age 65.
Often missed, much of the white collar pension benefits are accrued from voluntary pension contributions made by the worker while active, not payed by the company. That source of pension benefits is now sorely underfunded, through no fault of the employees.
I agree that the difference in age of the two parts of the industry is a significant aspect of the problem, combined with the different treatment by their respective home governments.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
Couldn't this UAW thing get 100x worse?
bk (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 10:21AM EST (link)What happens if in 2009 the card check bill passes and the UAW takes over all the auto plants in the US? It could happen right? I have no doubt that would be their plan if that monstrosity gets enacted.
I certainly hope the Republicans are 100%
mbecker908 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 10:42AM EST (link)behind a filibuster of any bailout that does not cause the UAW to give serious concessions. Any Republican Senator who refuses to support this requirement should lose their seniority.
Nope, 'becker, I'll guarantee you
Achance (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 11:08AM EST (link)that there’ll be some Republicans who believe that if they’re just nicer to UAW, the unions will love them and support them next time. Been there, done that; they’re like abused children.
In Vino Veritas
Yeah Art, I know that. And we can both list the
mbecker908 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 11:12AM EST (link)braindead fools who will be on their knees to the UAW. I wonder if there’s any chance we could pick up a blue dog in the cloture vote?
If they have the votes for "card check,"
Achance (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 10:45AM EST (link)and I think they do, they have the votes to amend the Labor-Management Relations Act to remove the ability of the States to prohibit union shops. The UAW and the Democrats solution to the uncompetitiveness of the “Big Three” will be to force the transplants under the UAW pattern agreement and the Southern plants into union shops.
Organized labor has been waiting and seething since 1948 for the opportunity to undo the Taft-Hartley Amendments to the National Labor Relations Act. Throw in that mandatory police, fire, and teacher bargaining law that the Democrats have had floating around for the last several years, and welcome to the Socialist Workers’ Paradise.
And, yes, I am serious; the first 100 Days of the BHO Administration are going to produce a totally different Country and the federal government is going to war against the Red States.
In Vino Veritas
Which will result in moving those factories overseas
Dave_in_Fla (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 11:56AM EST (link)And the follow on reaction on increased duty on imported cars to compensate for the union labor cost differential.
Interesting times we are about to live in.
“If they were merely incompetent, then at least SOME of their actions would have been to the benefit of the country.” – Joe McCarthy
It's not easy to close a unionized plant.
Achance (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 12:06PM EST (link)Look at all the attention that glass plant in Chicago is getting; imagine a big auto plant being closed down. It won’t take long for BHO to have a union dominated National Labor Relations Board; most of USDOL’s bureaucracy is holdover from Clinton anyway, so the whole might of the US will be brought to bear against any company trying to close a plant. I doubt that either the foreign owners or their governments will want to take on the US over this; they’ll just up the price.
This is really what both the UAW and the legacy management want: the good old days of pattern bargaining in which nobody cared what labor cost so long as it cost everybody the same thing.
In Vino Veritas
There is no way they shut down US plants.
mbecker908 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:30PM EST (link)They can be profitable and continue to gain market share even with cost parity with the Big 3.
Francis- One correction
Scope (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 11:33AM EST (link)I have read and heard that Gettlefinger said he was willing to “suspend” the jobs bank, not end it.
One of Detroits unions, under the UAW, I believe an axel union is leaving on a caravan today to go to Washington to beg the Government to save their jobs. The leader of that union is retired autoworker Wendy Thompson. She was on McConnells radio show on Sat. and argued that they shouldn’t have to have their pay cut as it is just at living standard, and that other automakers and companies need to come up to that level of pay. She fully supports Card Check, and gave every argument in the book for it, because she said it was “fair” and saw no reason to have secret ballots. McConnell argued that if a company was going to be forced out of business if they became unionized, the employees had a right to know that before voting for the union, Wendy did not agree. She also believes that the healthcare issue is so very important, and hopes that the Government takes on the Universal Healthcare issue, and actually said she hoped that “MEDICARE” is made available to EVERYONE, again because it is fair. There was also a site that came up in Google where they claimed that if Gettlefinger gives any concessions, he will be replaced, as the members do not believe in concessions to the workers. Sorry I don’t have the link to that site.
There is no question that Obama will “save” the automakers, so he can pay back his debt to the UAW for their $80 million dollars in donations to his and other liberals campaigns this year.
Yes he actually said "suspend" and take it from
Old_Crow (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 1:46PM EST (link)someone who has done face-to-face negotiations with the UAW, the word “suspend” is intentional. Gettlefinger has no intention and probably is not authorized by the union to offer ‘ending’ the jobs bank. As has been well stated here, an up-front concession from the UAW needs to be a requirement for any movement on taxpayer money (my preference is funding an controlled Chapter-11 process).
“Enlightened statesmen will not always be at the helm.” — James Madison
Never in a million years will UAW give up
Achance (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 2:05PM EST (link)anything when they know all they need to do is live til January 21 and they can get what they want. UAW and the management are allies in this holdup. The UAW can’t hate Bush specifically and Republicans generally any more than it already does, although there remain abused Republican children who still try to get unions to love them. Republicans, including the President should just sit on their hands, and force the management to face the music – but they won’t so the WH compromise deal that allows GWB to say it didn’t happen on his watch is probably the best that can be had.
In Vino Veritas
Then Threaten Chapter 7 Bankruptcy!
DavidS1787 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:07PM EST (link)n/t
You don't get it;
Achance (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 10:44PM EST (link)Management and the UAW are conconspirators in this. Management doesn’t want to do Chp. 11 or Chp. 7, they want the good old days of pattern bargaining.
In Vino Veritas
Chapter 11
DavidS1787 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:06PM EST (link)Like you, I prefer that The big three go through Chapter 11 bankruptcy and restructer than to give them 15 Billion that will most likely have no strings attached. The big three will come out leaner .
About the Unions:
Gettlefinger should be told by the Big Three to get
rid of the jobs bank or we will consider Chapter 7 then they won’t have jobs.
Remind him Chapter 11 is better than Chapter 7 Bankruptcy.
'Gettlefinger should be told by the Big Three...'
Diogenes314 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 7:12PM EST (link)That was funny. Next you’ll be saying the Dems in Congress might tell the unions to do something instead of vice versa.
BTW, it’s the little three, and the Big One. And its Congressional waterboys.
worse, it will have all the wrong strings attached
JLenardDetroit (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 7:18PM EST (link)rather than untying some of the knots they have the industry twisted up in. Like this Car Czar BS, unless it is an anti-Govt meddling Republican appointed that the Dem’s couldn’t immediately replace in 2 months… NO THANKS!!!
Regards from NoMoTown (the MOTORlessCITY)
“Liberals, looking to do for? America what they’ve done for? Detroit! which is DESTROY IT!”
“I think, therefore I am Conservative”
“Conservative by choice, Republican by necessity”
“You can lead a Liberal to the Truth/Facts, but you cannot make them THINK!”
“Romney [No, not my first choice] does NOT have a MORMON problem. He has a, far too many Americans; these days; are MORONS problem!”
Follow @JLenardDetroit
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (message) (Warning: Children Will Die!!)
Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” – a Rush caller (other Quotes)
Excellent point, Francis (n/t)
Dave_in_Fla (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 11:57AM EST (link).
“If they were merely incompetent, then at least SOME of their actions would have been to the benefit of the country.” – Joe McCarthy
Where is the money going to go??
fisk2521 Monday, December 8th at 4:20PM EST (link)I thought I heard on Fox today that the ‘bail-out’ for the automakers would not just necessarily jsut be targeted at USA based factories: i.e. the money could be used to ‘bail out’ GM, Chrysler or Ford plants in other countries.
I hope I misunderstood and heard this wrong, but I don’t think so. The journalist alluded to saving Chrysler and the others via foreign factories…… Can’t believe we’d do that with our tax money to be honest. All this talk about saving Americans jobs and preventing a higher unemployment rate which wil cause a depression and the jobs might be in another country???!!!!
LDavis
Workers Paradise
Warrior (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 4:56PM EST (link)is right. Just like The Clinton & Carter Admins bullied banks into making stupid loans, so the BHO/Pelosi?Reid crowd will force states into adopting all sorts of Marxist trash. (If not amend or redact the laws peremptorily as has already been pointed out. What are the chances of individual persecution and harrassment of redstaters by the IRS, DOL, EEOC, etc.? Am I being paranoid?
“Racial criteria are irrational, irrelevant, [and] odious to our way of life.” — Thurgood Marshall for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund in the 1950 Supreme Court case of McLaurin v. Oklahoma
Francis, I agree
redneck_hippie (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:11PM EST (link)with every point. Now since I only have Durbin in my state, I’ll try to select a suitable substitute since I don’t believe in wasting my time. Maybe I’ll give ole Lindsay a shout.
I hopeThe big three Ceo's are forced by their share holders
DavidS1787 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:11PM EST (link)to resign from their jobs.
What makes you believe
Flagstaff (Diary) Tuesday, December 9th at 4:15PM EST (link)that’s the right thing to do?
I don’t know about the others, but Alan Mulally seems to be part of the solution at Ford, not part of the problem. That’s why he was hired two years ago.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
How will the Obama admin sustain the auto industry?
asleep06 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:18PM EST (link)Since it seems unlikely that the federal govt will continually give these highly publicized bailouts to the Big 3 and tariffs seem to me to be too ineffective, what option will the Obama admin avail themselves of?
Will it be, as AChance and mbecker suggest, by passing various forms of equal compensation regulations for all auto companies operating in the US?
Small is beautiful.
The worst case scenario looks something like this...
mbecker908 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:28PM EST (link)(and I’m being optimistic)
1. GM, Chrysler & Ford get all the cash they want.
2. The UAW is required to give no concessions. FWIW, this really strengthens their hand going into the next contract.
3. Card check passes.
4. State right-to-work laws are invalidated.
5. Union elections are held at all currently non-union auto manufacturers. The unions make ACORN look like a kindergarten bug collecting club. They win all the elections.
6. New contracts force the price of foreign cars up by about $1,000.
7. GM, Chrysler & Ford continue to lose market share.
8. The feds pick up Big 3 legacy costs.
9. Big 3 undercuts foreign pricing by a tad.
10. Big 3 continues to lose market share.
11. Barney Frank nationalizes the auto industry.
Bingo
Jack_Savage (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:34PM EST (link)Exactly the scenario, and exactly in that order.
I Can One UP YOU
rcov092 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 7:55PM EST (link)There is a rumor floating that the “Car Czar” could be none other than UAW head Ron Gettlefinger. Can you believe the audacity (of Hope)?
“Not One Red Dime for the NRSC or NRCC till they stop trying to elect liberals”
Join the RedState Strike Force
Gettlefinger wouldn't be any worse than any
mbecker908 (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 8:38PM EST (link)member of congress or any of the Big 3 execs.
One thing's
Warrior (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:23PM EST (link)for sure. You can’t continue to pay high school drop-outs $75 an hour (not to mention healthcare, retirement, etc) and compete against the Japanese, I believe the free market should prevail and push these dinosaurs out of business. Of course, the free market never intended or accounted for predatory unions, gubmint interference and so on. However, it’s time for the big 3 to go.
“Racial criteria are irrational, irrelevant, [and] odious to our way of life.” — Thurgood Marshall for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund in the 1950 Supreme Court case of McLaurin v. Oklahoma
Where have I heard this before?
Jack_Savage (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 5:32PM EST (link)“But because this is an emergency situation, there’s been no time to fully debate the issue, and to deal with the fact that no one has bothered to try to convince the American people that their tax dollars should be used to reward a couple of badly-failed businesses.”
Deja vu all over again, and I am so damn sick and tired of this recurring nightmare. If the poor, downtrodden union workers would make it their business to be productive and help their companies make a profit instead of making it their business to elect Democrats, maybe things would be different at EVERY SINGLE UNIONIZED BUSINESS ON EARTH. But they won’t, so it won’t.
It will be a cold day in hell before my wife or I, my children, or my grandchildren buy a car made by one of the Big Three Bailout Whores / UAW.
And on top of that
bk (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 6:33PM EST (link)So much for Obama’s promises to reinstitute PAY-GO, bring fiscal discipline back to Washington, carefully review every dollar spent page by page and line by line, etc.
he's still promising that bs... line by line...
JLenardDetroit (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 6:37PM EST (link)but what he means is, they will scrutinize the DEFENSE BUDGET for any and all cuts they can find, not the General Budget.
Regards from NoMoTown (the MOTORlessCITY)
“Liberals, looking to do for? America what they’ve done for? Detroit! which is DESTROY IT!”
“I think, therefore I am Conservative”
“Conservative by choice, Republican by necessity”
“You can lead a Liberal to the Truth/Facts, but you cannot make them THINK!”
“Romney [No, not my first choice] does NOT have a MORMON problem. He has a, far too many Americans; these days; are MORONS problem!”
Follow @JLenardDetroit
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (message) (Warning: Children Will Die!!)
Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” – a Rush caller (other Quotes)
President Bush deserves GREAT credit for reducing the initial bailout
Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Monday, December 8th at 11:21PM EST (link)by nearly a third. Bush’s purpose was not to kick the can down the road. If we know one thing about President Bush, it is that he is not afraid of taking heat for cans immediately obstructing the road he presently travels.
more later
Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson